September 7, 2009
Happy Labor Day! I suppose summer is officially over now. As a final salute to the season, I have a recipe for you. I haven’t been in the kitchen this weekend, so please forgive me for not including photos! But trust me, this recipe is family-tested and approved! And you already know what potato salad looks like anyway, right?
Here’s our world-famous SisFamily Potato Salad recipe, which originally came from SisMama’s dad. Ok, it might not actually be world-famous, but our family loves it! What makes it special? No to celery, green pepper, sweet relish and Miracle Whip! Yes to celery salt, a touch of mustard, boiled eggs and dill pickles. That’s how we roll!
SisFamily Potato Salad
3 to 4 pounds new potatoes, as close to the same size as possible
6 eggs, boiled and chopped
1 small red onion, finely chopped
4 to 6 dill pickles, finely chopped or use dill relish
2 tablespoons yellow or spicy brown mustard
Good mayonnaise to bind it all together: usually 1 cup or more
Celery salt to taste
Salt and pepper to taste
Boil the potatoes (unpeeled) until just tender. Allow to cool just enough to handle and then peel. They peel easier when they’re still warm. Cut potatoes into medium-size chunks; not too small. They break up a bit when mixed, and you don’t want to be left with mashed potato salad. Salt and pepper the pieces while still warm, since they absorb flavors best while warm. Set aside.
In a large bowl, mix the egg, onion, and pickles together. Add the mustard, mayonnaise and a few dash of celery salt. Mix all together, then add in the potatoes and toss together gently. Taste and adjust for seasonings. You may need to add more mayonnaise to hold the mixture together. The potatoes will drink up some of the moisture as they sit for a while, so we usually make the salad pretty juicy to start with. It’s best to make the salad a day ahead or at least a couple of hours in advance so all of the flavors can blend.
For a lower-fat variation, you could use low-fat mayo, but we aren’t big fans of that product. And here’s a tip that I learned from a co-worker. To mellow your chopped raw onions a bit, let them marinate for an hour or so in plain water or in lemon juice, then drain them and pat them dry. The liquid takes out some of the bitter strong flavor. It really works! You could also substitute chopped chives or scallions for a milder flavor.
Potato salad is a main course in my veggie household, but it’s just a side dish in LilSis’ household of carnivorous guys. Fortunately for them, she has an awesome brisket recipe and she’s going to post it for all of you with similar big appetites in your family. Take it away, LilSis!