Make Ahead Mashed Potatoes: Holiday Potatoes

November 23, 2009

Holiday Potatoes

Holiday Potatoes

I wonder how many homes across America will have mashed potatoes on their dinner tables on Thursday? I know we will. We're really excited this year because we've been invited to spend Thanksgiving with SirHoney's cousin and some of her extended family.

One of my contributions for this Thanksgiving Dinner is mashed potatoes, so of course, I'll be making BigSis' infamous, “go to” mashed potato recipe, Holiday Potatoes.

BigSis has been making this mashed potato recipe for our Thanksgiving and Christmas celebrations for many years now. When we had all our kids at home, she would start with 10 pounds of potatoes in order to bring two 13 x 9 dishes for my hungry guys!

This recipe is actually in a cookbook that she put together over 20 years ago and she's always called them Holiday Potatoes. If you browse the Internet, you'll find similar recipes called Refrigerator Potatoes or Make Ahead Mashed Potatoes. The quantities vary slightly.

(I made a couple of changes this time. I added the garlic cloves, omitted the nutmeg, and added the fried shallots.)

Holiday Potatoes

9 large potatoes (I used white, but you can use Russet or Yukon Gold) peeled and quartered
4 cloves garlic, peeled
1 stick butter, softened
12 oz. cream cheese, softened
1 c. sour cream
3 large shallots, peeled and thinly sliced
1 1/2 c. canola oil
salt and pepper to taste

Place the potatoes and the garlic cloves in a large saucepan and add water to cover. Boil until potatoes are tender. Meanwhile, in a medium skillet, heat the oil until hot, add the shallots and cook over medium heat, stirring frequently, until they are golden, about 15 minutes. Using a slotted spoon, transfer the shallots to a paper towel to drain.

Once tender, drain and place the potatoes in a large bowl. Cut butter and cream cheese into small pieces and add to bowl. Beat with electric mixer until potatoes are fluffy. Beat in sour cream. Add salt and pepper to taste. Serve immediately or place in a buttered casserole dish and refrigerate.

To reheat, bake for 20 minutes or so at 350 degrees. (I like heating mine until they're a little brown around the edges.) Right before serving, sprinkle the shallots with salt and garnish the potatoes with the shallots.

Mashed Potatoes

I really liked the addition of the garlic cloves; it gave the potatoes just a very slight garlic taste. I LOVE garlic, so next time I might even add a couple more cloves.

Making the mashed potatoes this way really saves the hassle of having to beat the potatoes at the very last minute. I'm making mine on Wednesday and will refrigerate overnight, allowing me to work on other things on Thursday morning.

You might remember that this past Easter, BigSis and I thought it would be fun to do something a little different, so we turned our mashed potatoes into this Pink Potatotini.

Pink Potatotini

Pink Potatotini

I won't be making pink potatoes for Thanksgiving, but you just can't go wrong with this recipe for Holiday Potatoes. If you happen to make them for the first time, please let me know what you think! 🙂


If you liked this...

4 Comments so far

  1. Posted by lisaiscooking

    November 23, 20091:40 pm

    I can’t wait for the mashed potatoes on Thursday! I rarely indulge in this lovely side dish, but it’s my favorite at holiday time. Love the make-ahead idea!
    .-= lisaiscooking´s last blog post … Roasted Vegetables with a Maple Balsamic Glaze =-.

  2. Posted by BigSis

    November 23, 20096:02 pm

    Our table will DEFINITELY have these taters on it, and I’m so excited that BigT is going to help us eat them this year!

    I love your addition of the garlic and fried shallots! I always leave out the nutmeg and add a little garlic powder or salt since I like the touch of garlic too! Someday we’ll have to add a layer of shredded cheese to the top, since they don’t have enough calories or fat grams.

  3. Posted by SA

    November 25, 20093:54 pm

    I’m trying them, too! So nice not to have to worry about potatoes on Thanksgiving day…
    Thanks for the post!

  4. Posted by BigSis

    November 25, 20096:03 pm

    We hope you love them, SA! I just finished putting my batch together. Report back and let us know how your family likes these!


  1. Posted by Tweets that mention Make Ahead Mashed Potatoes: Holiday Potatoes | BigSisLilSis --

    November 24, 20099:24 am

  2. Posted by Make Ahead Mashed Potatoes: Holiday Potatoes | Welcome To Recipe Idea

    June 20, 20113:49 am

  3. Posted by Cool Mash Potatoes Recipes images | Potato Recipes

    July 9, 20116:21 am

  4. Posted by Cool Potato Recipes images |

    August 27, 20111:47 pm

  5. Posted by Make Ahead Mashed Potatoes: Holiday Potatoes - Home Restaurant Recipes

    August 29, 201110:00 am

  6. Posted by Cool Potato Recipes images | Cooking Blog

    November 19, 20114:00 am

  7. Posted by Make Ahead Mashed Potatoes: Holiday Potatoes | Dinner Recipe Ideas

    July 7, 20127:16 pm

  8. Posted by Holiday Potatoes | Dinner Recipe Ideas

    July 11, 201211:16 pm

  9. Posted by Make Ahead Mashed Potatoes: Holiday Potatoes | Mim's Recipes & Cookbooks – Around the World

    August 10, 20135:39 am

  10. Posted by Cool Make Mashed Potatoes images | Make Potato

    September 9, 201312:22 am

More Blog Posts

Previous Post: